Social and National Identity Cooperation in Iran: ‎A Case Study of the Qashqa’i Tribe and the Oil ‎Nationalization Movement

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Professor, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Law & Political ‎Science, University of Tehran, Iran

2 A PhD Candidate, Middle Eastern Studies, Department Humanities, ‎Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden‎

Abstract

The relation between tribal/ethnic identity and national identity has become a subject of recent studies in Iran. While many consider these identities as mutually conflictual ones, this paper focuses on the mutual operational relations among them and emphasizes that this pattern has been dominant in the post-Islamic period in Iran. The Iranian tribal groups have had remarkable role in many socio-political movements in Iran. Before collapsing in its entirety, Iran’s nomadic tribes were political agents with considerable impact on the country's social and political events. Just as the Iranian Constitutional Revolution divided the tribal forces into the pro- and anti-revolutionary factions, so too the nationalization of the Iranian oil industry witnessed the same political situation among the nomadic tribes. The movement for the nationalization of the oil industry and the 1953 Iranian coup d’état in addition to the political stance taken by the leaders of Iran’s nomadic tribes in reaction to these events are of considerable importance. In the present article, we focus on a case study of Qashqa’i tribal confederacy and investigate the reasons their leaders chose to support the nationalization movement of Mohammad Mosaddegh and fight against the 1953 coup d’état.
The main research questions raised in the paper are as follows: 1. What were the political views and positions of Qashqa’i leaders on the nationalization of the oil industry in Iran? 2. What factors influenced the formation of the Qashqa’i leaders’ opinions on this issue and their attitudes towards the nationalization movement in Iran? The research hypothesis is that the Qashqa’i people’s support for Mosaddegh and the nationalization movement rests on three axes: i) a concern about the Pahlavi’s coming back into power and resuming their authoritarianism and the pattern of Reza Shah’s rule; ii) the friendly relations between the Qashqa’i leaders and Dr. Mosaddegh; iii) Qashqa’i leaders believe in the linkage between tribal identity and national identity which led the leaders to prioritize national interest over tribal interest. To answer the research questions and help understand the views of the Qashqa'i leaders towards the historical events culminating in the nationalization of Iran’s oil industry, this paper analyses archival evidence taken from the relevant documents in the National Library and Archives of Iran, specifically the records of communication between Prime Minister Mossadegh and the key Qashqa’i leaders. Furthermore, personal accounts and observations of these leaders as presented in their published autobiographies, memoirs and the interview transcripts in the Iranian Oral History Project are examined.
Theoretically, the authors rely on the identity level of analysis and cooperation, rather than on conflict between social and national identities in Iran which had been promoted in the works of the first author. According to Ahmadi’s previous research on the types and degree of influence of the Tribes in Iran’s political activism and struggles, the tribal communities in Iran have been different from the tightly knit cultural or political groups which have habitually been in permanent conflict with the governments. On the contrary, the Iranian tribal groups have had much cultural and religious communality with other Iranians on the national level and have cooperated with different Iranian governments in the past. Iran’s tribal leaders and people have not considered their tribal identity (denoted as social identity in this study) to be in constant conflict with the Iranian national identity. The case of the Qashqa’i tribe and its involvement in the 1951 oil nationalization movement reflect such constructive relations.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1.  References

    1. Ahmadi, H (2011). Bonyād’hā-ye hoviat-e melli Iran: chārchob-e Nazari-ye hoviyat-e melli-ye shahr’vand’mehvar, Foundations of Iranian National Identity: The Theoretical Framework of Citizen-Oriented National Identity, Tehran: Research Center for Cultural and Social Studies. [In Persian]
    2. Ahmadi, H (2020). Ghomiyat and ghom’garāi dar Iran, Ethnicity and Ethnocentrism in Iran, Tehran: Ney, 16th ed. [In Persian]
    3. Bākhtar-e emroz (The West Today). (1953, April 16) 6. [In Persian]
    4. Bayat, K (2020). Nabard-e semiram (The Battle of Semiram). Tehran: Khojasteh. [In Persian]
    5. Beck, L (2017). Qhashghāi-ye Iran (The Qashqa'i of Iran), trans. Hamid Reza Jahandideh. Tehran: Nezareh. [In Persian]
    6. Burrell, R.E; Robert, J, eds. (1997). Iran Political Diaries, 1881-1965. Cambridge, UK: Archive Editions, V. 13.
    7. Dardari, N (2016). Tārikh-e siyāsi ejtemāʿi ill-e bozorg-e ghashghāi, Social Political History of the Great Qashqa’i Tribe, Shiraz: Qashqai Publications. [In Persian]
    8. Estakhr roz’nāmeh (Estakhr Newspaper). (1946, October 14) 4. [In Persian]
    9. Jafari, R. (2000). Center-Periphery Relations in Iran, the Case of the Southern Rebellion in 1946, a Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
    10. (1988). Gozashteh cherāgh-e rāh-e āyandeh ast: tārikh-e Īrān dar fāseleh-ye du kodetā, 1299-1332, The Past is the Light of the Future: Iran's History between the Two Coups, 1920-1953, Farid Moradi, ed. Tehran: Qoqnos, 5th ed. [In Persian]
    11. Keddie, N.R. (1996). The Roots of the Iranian Revolution, trans. Abdol Rahim Govahi. Tehran: Islamic Culture Publishing House, 2nd ed. [In Persian]
    12. Kiani, M (2009). Siyāh’chādor’hā: tahghighi az zendegi-ye mardom-e ill-e qashghāi (Black Tents: A Study of the Life of Qashqa’i People). Tehran: Kian. [In Persian]
    13. Majale-ye khāndani’hā (Khāndani’hā Magazine). (1952). 23. [In Persian]
    14. Makki, H (1995). Tārikh-e bist’sāleh-ye Iran (Twenty-Year History of Iran). Tehran: Elmi, 5th ed. [In Persian]
    15. Movahed, M.A (2014a). Khāb-e āshofteh: az gharārdād-e dārci ta soghoot-e rezā shāh (The Troubled Dream of Oil: From the Darcy Concession to the Fall of Reza Shah). Tehran: Karnameh, V. 1. [In Persian]
    16. Movahed, M.A (2014b). Khāb-e āshofteh: Doctor Mosadegh and nehzat-e melli-ye Īrān, The Troubled Dream of Oil: Dr. Mossadegh and Iran's National Movement, Tehran: Karnameh, V. 2 and 3. [In Persian]
    17. Nāmeh-ye mosadegh b khosrow gashghāi (Mossadegh's Letter to Khosrow Qashqai)," (1962, August) Nāmeh Noor. Tehran: National Library Document Center, 4. [In Persian]
    18. Nasiri-Taibi, M (2014). Ill-e ghashghāi dar tārikh-e moʿāser-e Iran, The Qashqa’i Tribe in the Contemporary History of Iran, Tehran: Exsir. [In Persian]
    19. Noorizadeh Bushehri, I (1948). Asrār-e nehzat-e jenob (The Secrets of the Southern Movement). Tehran: Tabesh. [In Persian]
    20. Oberling, P (2006). “Siyāsat-e ghabileh’ī-ye engelis dar jenob-e Iran, British Tribal Policy in Southern Iran,” trans. Kaveh Bayat. Nāmeh Noor. 4-5: 66-114. Available at: https://ensani.ir/file/download/ article/ 20120506102654-7093-25.pdf (Accessed 5 October 2020). [In Persian]
    21. Oberling, P (2014). The Qashqai Nomads of Fars, trans. Farhad Tayibipoor. Tehran: Pardis Danesh. [In Persian]
    22. Qashqaei, M.H (2005). Yād’māndeh (Memorial). Tehran: Farzan. [In Persian]
    23. Qashqaei, M.N (1992). Sāl’hā-ye bohrān, khāterāt-e rozāneh-ye Mohammad Naser ghashghāi (Crisis Years, Mohammed Naser Qashqai's Diary). Tehran: Rasa. [In Persian]
    24. Qashqaei, M.N (2010). "Khāterāt-e mohammad nāser ghashghāi (Memoirs of Mohammad Nasser Qashqaei)," Iranian Oral History Project, Interviewer Habib Lajevardi, Interview Location Las Vegas, Interview Date 31 January 1983, Tapes 1 and 2, Middle Eastern Division, Widener Library, Harvard University. Available at: https://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:FHCL:1115622 (Accessed 27 October 2021). [In Persian]
    25. Qashqai, Kh (1979, August 19). "I Prefer Having a Newspaper and be Insulted than Not Having a Newspaper," Roznāmeh-ye Parkhāsh, Parkhash Newspaper, No. 19, Sunday. [In Persian]
    26. Qashqai, M.Ma (2015). Khāterāt-e malek mansoor ghashghāi (Memoirs of Malek Mansour Qashqhai). Tehran: Namak.
    27. Roz’nāmeh-ye Ettelāʿāt, Ettelāʿāt Newspaper, (1953). 27, 8042: 3. [In Persian]
    28. Shaygan, A (2005). Seyed Ali shāygān, zendegi’nāmeh siyāsi, neveshteh’hā, sokhanrāni’hā (Seyed Ali Shaygan, Political Biography, Writings, Speeches). Tehran: Aghah, V. 1. [in Persian]
    29. Wilbur, D (2000). Asnād-e sāzemān-e siā darbāreh-ye kodetā-ye 28 mordād and sarnegoni-ye doctor Mosāddegh (CIA Documents on the August 28 Coup and the Overthrow of Dr. Mossadegh), trans. Gholamreza Watandoost. Tehran: Rasa. [In Persian]
    30. Yazdan Panah, M (2020). Sākhtār-e siyāsi and ejtemāʿi-ye ill: bāz’namāi-ye sāz’o’kār’hā-ye mashroiyat’bakhsh ghodrat-e illi: motāleʿh-ye moredi-ye ill-e ghashghāi, Political and Social Construction of Tribe: Representation of Legitimizing Mechanisms of Tribal Power: A Case Study of Qashqa’i Tribe, Master's Thesis, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, Iran. [In Persian]

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 05 January 2022
  • Revise Date: 24 November 2022
  • Accept Date: 24 April 2023

Share

How to cite

Statistics